Product Ratings · 7 rated
Meal replacement shakes rated for weight management
Shakes sold to replace a meal. Meal replacement bars are rated in their own category. Each product is rated only on how well it suits weight management, and ranked against the others here
NeuMeal
Nutty Harmony
1st of 7 in meal replacement shakes
4.5
out of 5
Very good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 5.0
- Ingredient quality
- 4.6
- Taste
- 4.0
- Affordability
- 3.5
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
OZiva
Nutritional Meal for Women Chocolate
2nd of 7 in meal replacement shakes
4.3
out of 5
Good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 4.6
- Ingredient quality
- 4.2
- Taste
- 3.7
- Affordability
- 4.1
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
NeuMeal
Spicy
3rd of 7 in meal replacement shakes
4.0
out of 5
Good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 4.3
- Ingredient quality
- 4.6
- Taste
- 3.5
- Affordability
- 2.5
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
Nestlé Health Science
Optifast Vanilla Shake
4th of 7 in meal replacement shakes
3.9
out of 5
Good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 4.3
- Ingredient quality
- 3.8
- Taste
- 4.0
- Affordability
- 2.4
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
Horlicks
PRO Fitness Chocolate Flavour
5th of 7 in meal replacement shakes
3.8
out of 5
Good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 3.6
- Ingredient quality
- 4.2
- Taste
- 4.0
- Affordability
- 3.6
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
Herbalife Nutrition
Formula 1 Nutritional Shake Mix Mango
6th of 7 in meal replacement shakes
3.7
out of 5
Good fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 3.6
- Ingredient quality
- 2.9
- Taste
- 3.6
- Affordability
- 5.0
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
Abbott
Ensure Chocolate
7th of 7 in meal replacement shakes
3.0
out of 5
Moderate fit for weight management
- Formula and evidence
- 2.1
- Ingredient quality
- 2.9
- Taste
- 4.3
- Affordability
- 4.6
Reviewed 8 Nov 2026
Ranked by overall rating; ties are listed alphabetically. Affordability compares cost per serving and per gram of protein within this category. Scored 2026-11-08. How we rate.